Loading...

Toggle Health Problems and D

Vitamin D3 far better than D2 for hemodialysis – Oct 2012

Vitamin D2 versus vitamin D3 supplementation in hemodialysis patients:
a comparative pilot study.

Daroux M, Shenouda M, Bacri JL, Lemaitre V, Vanhille P, Bataille P
Department of Nephrology, Doctor Duchenne Hospital, Boulogne-sur-Mer - France; and Department of Nephrology, Regional University Hospital of Lille, Lille - France.
Journal of Nephrology [2012:0]

Background: In patients with chronic kidney disease, vitamin D insufficiency is highly prevalent. It can be corrected by supplementation with either vitamin D2 or vitamin D3. Recent studies in patients without impaired kidney function suggest that vitamin D3 is more efficient than vitamin D2 in correcting vitamin D insufficiency. However, no direct comparison has been made in hemodialysis (HD) patients.

Methods: Thirty-nine HD patients with serum 25-hydroxyvitamin D (25(OH)D) levels =20 ng/mL were enrolled in this comparative, prospective pilot study.
They were divided into 3 groups and treated over a 3-month period.
Each patient received oral doses of 200,000 international units (IU) vitamin D per month according to the following treatment schedule:

(i) vitamin D2 in small fractionated doses at each HD session, 3 times per week (group D2S);
(ii) vitamin D2 once a month (group D2M); or
(iii) vitamin D3 once a month (group D3M).

Changes in serum 25(OH)D levels were measured at the end of the study.

Results: Posttreatment serum 25(OH)D levels increased significantly in all groups.
The mean ± SD serum 25(OH)D value for group D3M patients (40 ± 13 ng/mL) was significantly higher than that for groups D2M (25 ± 9 ng/mL, p<0.01) and D2S patients (25 ± 9 ng/mL, p<0.01).
Serum 25(OH)D increased to levels >30 ng/mL in

84% of group D3M patients, but in only
15% and 27% of group D2M and D2S subjects, respectively.

Conclusion: Vitamin D3 is more effective than vitamin D2 in providing adequate 25(OH)D serum levels in HD patients.
PMID:22641581

See also VitaminDWiki

Vitamin D3 far better than D2 for hemodialysis – Oct 2012

6968 visitors, last modified 24 Aug, 2013,

Printer Friendly Follow this page for updates

This page is in the following categories (# of items in each category)

Kidney 206 Vitamin D3 instead of D2 93

Edit

“One pill every two weeks fights diabetes, cancers, heart failure, and 21 other diseases.”

Click for details

Health Problems and D

15,500+ pages in VitaminDWiki
Topic (# in topic)

Acne (20+ studies)

Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder/ADHD (49+)

Alcohol (29+)

Allergy (120+) Overview

Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis/ALS (30+)

Alzheimer's (81+) Overview

Ankylosing Spondylitis (20+)

Antibiotics/Probiotics (92+) Overview

Asthma (145+) Overview

Atopic Dermatitis Overview (18+)

Autism (157+) Overview

Vit. D Receptor (14+)

Transgender (19+)

Autoimmune (199+)

Systemic Sclerosis (10+)

Back Pain (43+)

Lumbar Degeneration (14+)

Bipolar Disorder (16+)

Bone - Health (311+)

BMD, Bone loss (55+)

Breathing (450+)

Hay Fever (20+)

Pneumonia (50+)

Respiratory (82+)

Burns/Wounds (30+)

Cancer (292+) Overview

After diagnosis (113+)

Bladder (28+)

Bone (8+)

Breast (256+) Overview

Child (16+)

Colon (144+) Overview

Endometrial (5+)

Gastric (9+)

Leukemia (19+)

Liver (17+)

Lung (55+) Overview

Lymphoma (26+)

Mg and Cancer (13+)

Melanoma (43+)

Multiple Myeloma (10+)

Metastatic (17+)

Other (66+)

Ovarian (26+)

Palliative Care (10+)

Pancreatic (57+)

Prostate (103+) Overview

Skin (121+) Overview

Survive (37+)

Thyroid (7+)

{DIV}

Cardiovascular (526+) Overview

Atherosclerosis (56+)

Atrial Fibrillation (20+)

Heart Failure (47+)

HRV (10+)

Omega-3 (38+)

Statins (80+)

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome (12+)

Cerebral Palsy (6+)

Cholesterol (52+) Overview

Chronic Fatigue (7) Overview

Cognitive (389+) Overview

Anesthesia ==> Cog

Brain (103+)

Delirium (9+)

Dementia (50+)

Mental Illness (300+)

Mental Stress (10+)

Colds/flu Overview

Concussions (25+)

Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease/COPD (17+)

COVID-19 (1300+)

Cystic Fibrosis (51+)

Dental (116+)

Fluoridation (16)

Depression (267+)

Anxiety ( 11+)

Omega-3 (29)

SAD (9)

Diabetes (548+) Overview

Hemodialysis (41+)

Magnesium (27+)

Meta-analyses (39+)

Metabolic Syndrome + Mg

Neuropathy (15+)

Prediabetes (30+)

Red Meat (4+)

Retinopathy (8+)

Type 1 Diabetes (46+)

Vitamin D Receptor (23+)

Zinc (5+)

Diseases general (93+)

Ear (17+)

Otitis Media (10+)

Endometriosis (8+)

Falls/Fractures (258+) Overview

Fatigue, Chronic Overview

Fertility/Sperm (141+)

Erectile Dysfunction (12+)

In Vitro Fert. (18+)

Testosterone (14+)

Fibromyalgia Overview

Fractures Overview

Ankle (16+)

Bone & Stress Fractures

Bone Mineral Density (28+)

Children (16+)

Hip Fractures (68+)

Vertigo (22+)

Genetics (343+)

CYP24A1 (31+)

CYP24R1 (25+)

CYP27B1 (62+)

Epigenetics (18+)

Telomere (12+)

Vit D Binding (177+)

Vit D Receptor (517+)

Cancer in VDR (79+)

Gestational Diabetes (34+)

Gout (13+)

Gut (206+) Overview

Bariatric (15+)

Celiac (7+)

Clostridium difficile (9+)

Crohn's (38+)

IBD (28+)

IBS (18+)

Ulcerative Colitis (12+)

Hair (20+)

Alopecia Areata (8+)

Health - general (109+)

Human Immunodeficiency Virus/HIV (45+) Overview

Hives (10+)

Hypertension (166+) Overview

Pregnancy (41+)

Hyperparathyroid Overview

Immunity (273+)

Inflammation (173+)

CRP (19+)

Infection (141+)

Influenza Overview

Kidney (228+) Overview

Chronic Kidney (63+)

Dialysis (39+)

Kidney Stones (29+) Overview

Leprosy (16+)

Liver (102+) Overview

Hepatitis-B (12+)

Hepatitis-C (13+)

NAFLD (27+)

Lyme Disease (9+)

Lupus (77+)

Mental Illness (20+)

Mental Stress (5+)

Metabolic Syndrome (105+) Overview

Mortality (296+)

Multiple Sclerosis (412+) Overview

Genetics and Receptor (32+)

Virus (16+)

Muscle (113+)

Handgrip (12+)

Sarcopenia (30+)

Muscular Dystrophy (9+)

Myopia (17+)

Obesity (441+)Overview

Child & Youth (60+)

Vitamin D Receptor (16+)

Virus and Obesity (25+)

Weight Loss (31+)

Osteoarthritis (60+) Overview

Knee (26+)

Osteoporosis (218+) Overview

BMD (26+)

Pain - chronic (165+) Overview

Magnesium (13+)

Pancreatitis (20+)

Parkinson's (117+) Overview

Pneumonia (22+)

Pollution (31+)

Pregnancy (918+) Overview

Breastfed (38+)

Caesarean (15+)

Depression (21+)

Dark Skin (30+)

Gestational Diabetes (41+)

In Vitro Fert. (18+)

Iodine (21+)

Low Birth Weight (23+)

Magnesium (30+)

Miscarriage (31+)

Multiple Sclerosis (13+)

Omega-3 before and during (49+)

PCOS (15+)

Preeclampsia (55+)

Preterm (125+)

Preterm - Omega-3 (13+)

Stillbirth (8+)

Prostate - BPH (16+)

Psoriasis (72+)

Respiratory Tract Infection/RTI (8+)

Restless Legs Syndrome (15+)

Rheumatoid Arthritis (117+) Overview

Juvenile RA (9+)

Rickets (127+) Overview

Sarcopenia (28+)

Schizophrenia Overview

Sepsis (201+)

Sickle Cell (20+) Overview

Skin (120+) Overview

Aging

Atopic Dermatitis(27+)

Hives

Vitiligo (8+)

Sleep (101+)

Sleep Apnea(12+)

Smoking (83+)

Spinal Cord (20+)

Spinal Surgery (13+)

Statins (40+)

Stroke (131+) Overview

Cognitive Impairment (15+)

Depression (9+)

Ischemic (21+)

Thyroid/Parath. (82+) Overview

PTH (34+)

Trauma/Surgery (347+)

Bariatric surgery (12+)

Bone surgery (23+)

ICU & Loading Dose (69+)

Need Vit D (69+)

Ortho. & Hip (69+)

Sepsis (41+)

Transplant (31+)

Traumatic Brain Injury (24+)

Tuberculosis (124+) Overview

Urinary Tract Infection (15+)

Virus (1391+)

All studies

Bird Flu

Cardiovascular (19+)

Cancers after VAX (17+)

Child - years after VAX (11+)

Cognitive (10+)

Dengue (27+)

Epstein-Barr Virus (20+)

Excess Deaths (23+)

Hepatitis (29+)

Herpes or Shingles (13+)

Ivermectin (35+)

Long-COVID (72+)

Magnesium (60+)

Masks (11+)

Meta-analyses (40+)

Omega-3 (14+)

Pfizer (20+)

RSV (12+)

Ultraviolet light (16+)

Vaccination (198+)

Vitamin D (650+)

Vitamin D Receptor (31+)

Vitamin K

Zinc (32+)

Vision (110+)

Cataracts (12+)

Dry Eye (15+)

Glaucoma (8+)

Macular Degeneration (14+)

Myopia (20+)

People and Low Vitamin D

Infant/Child (850+)

Allergy (36+)

Cancer (13+)

Cerebral Palsy (15+)

Down Syndrome (5+)

Fracture, low energy (10+)

Growing Pains (10+)

Pneumonia (25+)

Preemie (25+)

Puberty early if low D (9+)

Respiratory (21+)

RSV (25+)

Tonsils (9+)

Vaccination (10+)

Virus (42+)

Military (27+)

Veterans (17+)

Prisoners (14+)

Seniors (431+) Overview

Aging (38+)

Essential Tremor (4+)

Frailty (20+)

Longevity (47+)

Nursing Homes (19+)

Sarcopenia (25+)

Urinary incontinence (15+)

Vertigo (22+)

Skin - Dark (460+) Overview

Pregnancies (30+)

Sports (277+) Overview

Exercise (68+)

Muscle (138+)

Traumatic Brain Inj. (24+)

Women (196+) Overview

Endometriosis (25+)

Incontinence (16+)

Menopause (17+)

PCOS

Premenstrual Syndrome (20+)

Uterine Fibroid (13+)

Yeast Infection

Youth (173+)

Early Puberty (15+)

Locations

World (14+)

Aust NZ (68+)

Africa (28+)

Europe (233+)

India (65+)

Iceland (40+)

Middle East (152+)

Orient (76+)

Russia (12+)

Scotland (20+)

Far from Equator (124+)

Click here to search the site
A list includes 282+ pages having many studies
# of studies as of Oct 20, 2024